Under review by the monitor's administration
Exchange is withholding $28k on exchange XMR — SOL
I created a trade for XMR — SOL. By accident I had input my ETH wallet instead of SOL address. No big deal, I left a message to support telling them they can send me ETH instead. I made similar mistake with another exchange several months ago and they fixed it in 30 minutes so I didn't think much of it and thought it would be resolved quickly too. I was very wrong.
They said they can't change details without security. I asked them to simply process to the original ETH address in the order itself instead of SOL it wasn't a big deal. According to them first it was "security issue", when that excuse was defeated by me pointing out the original address is ETH and they can send to ETH, suddenly their excuse was that "changing the direction of the exchange" was security issue.
Okay I asked how to prove this and resolve this. According to their policies they send me a request for a video to prove I am the owner of the payment. I didn't receive it on my email because I already left to travel for business and holidays and I'll be home only in late January.
I said I have access to the wallet I sent from and can prove. I provided them with hash ID, amount and tx key (which in Monero only the owner can have). They said the only way was to send a video. This is where the clown situation starts coming into full force because they wanted a video to show what I already gave them as text as irrefutable proof.
I said to myself, okay they clearly don't understand the technical element and that the hash ID and tx ID of the monero transaction WITHOUT A DOUBT proves I am the owner of that transaction. Let me make the video.
The video was of the official monero command line, of me logging in, showing the transaction in question on my transaction page of the wallet and then as bonus getting the tx key infront of them with the get_tx_key command. It passed all of their requirements.
After sending the video now they have come back saying
"The video must be recorded directly from the wallet or exchange platform you used to make the payment. In your case, you used a third-party service with command-line operations.
I would also like to clarify that, during your conversation with our support operator, you were informed that we do not need to review your other transactions and that their contents are not important to us. However, this does not mean that the transaction history page itself can be omitted from the video. This requirement still applies, and the transaction history page must also be visible in the recording.
Additionally, since you used a third-party service to provide the payment information, we were unable to verify that the page had been refreshed before the recording began."
According to them an official CLI wallet from the Monero project is 3rd party. Laughter in the room for their complete technical incompetence.
I asked them explicitly of the operator if I need to show my transactions page and they said no. Suddenly, as an excuse, they are requesting to see my ENTIRE transaction page despite the operator saying they don't care about that part of the video. The video clearly showcases my transaction, time, date, amount all the requirements of their video. Imagine such an invasion of privacy and this isn't mentioned ANYWHERE in their policies. No exchange should force you to show ALL of your trades. Absolute circus!
They are now using this as excuse not to process and withhold my money. I have used them for many years and many friends and family have used them too after I recommended. However I now very much regret. Their exchange has always been smooth but their support and ridiculous policies are insane. Despite proving with technical terms I am the owner of the transaction and exchange, they refuse to release my payment or make the exchange.
I request the bestchange admin to review the case I am more than happy to provide all confidential details including the video and details I have provided to their incompetent team. Thank you.
Expand (0)
CommentRemove